A rejected return is not a failed return. It is a return the IRS did not accept for processing, and until you fix it and it is accepted, it counts as not filed. Most rejects come from a short list of causes, and most take minutes to fix if you know where to look. This guide covers six of the most common ones, how long you have to fix a reject, and a routine that prevents many of them.
First: read the whole reject, not just the first line
Your software shows a reject code and a message. Copy the full text and fix every error listed: fixing only the first one can send the return back with another reject. The codes below are examples. They change by tax year, so check your software's reject text and the IRS e-file pages before acting.
1. The prior-year AGI or PIN does not match (IND-031-04)
The IRS checks identity by comparing the taxpayer's prior-year adjusted gross income (AGI) or prior-year Self-Select PIN. If either one matches, processing continues. If neither does, the return rejects.
- Use the AGI from the original return as filed. Not the amount from an amended return, a corrected figure from a math-error notice or a change made by the IRS.
- A negative AGI has to be entered as a negative number.
- If the couple files jointly this year but filed separately last year, each spouse uses their own prior-year AGI or PIN.
- If the client switched software, the prior-year values do not carry over: enter them by hand.
- A client with an IP PIN uses it for this check instead (see reason 3).
2. The name, SSN or date of birth does not match Social Security records
The IRS expects names and SSNs to match what the Social Security Administration has, including spelling. The date of birth must match too.
- A typo is the easy case: correct it and send the return again.
- A very common real cause is a name change from marriage or divorce that was never reported to the Social Security Administration.
- If the entry is right and the mismatch is in SSA's record, the client has to fix it with SSA. You cannot clear it from your side.
- If it cannot be cleared, the return goes on paper. Per the IRS e-file mandate FAQ, a preparer subject to the mandate attaches Form 8948 (Preparer Explanation for Not Filing Electronically) and notes the reject code and number of attempts.
3. An IP PIN is missing or wrong
If the IRS issued an Identity Protection PIN to the taxpayer, the spouse or a dependent, a return without the right one is rejected. The reject tells you whose IP PIN it wants. The client gets a new IP PIN each year, so last year's will not work.
- The client can retrieve a lost IP PIN online or have it reissued.
- Reissue by mail is not available if the client first opted into the program this calendar year, or during the end-of-year maintenance period, which the IRS says normally runs from November to mid-January. Ask for the IP PIN at intake, not in March.
4. A dependent's SSN was already used on another return (IND-507-01)
This one changed. For tax year 2024 and later, the IRS says it accepts e-filed Forms 1040, 1040-NR and 1040-SS even if a dependent has already been claimed, and a return with a valid primary-taxpayer IP PIN will not reject for a duplicate dependent.
- Acceptance is not entitlement. The IRS notes that both returns being accepted does not mean both filers can claim the credits. Expect a notice by mail if the IRS finds duplicate claims, and keep the proof of who qualifies.
- For 2023 and earlier tax years, a duplicate dependent still has to be filed by mail.
- Check the SSN first. A typo is the usual cause; sometimes another family member claimed the child, and sometimes it is identity theft.
- If the reject says the taxpayer's own SSN was already used on another return, treat it as a possible identity-theft signal and read the IRS identity-theft guidance before you refile.
5. Form 8962 is missing (F8962-070)
If IRS records show the client received advance payments of the premium tax credit, the return needs Form 8962. Without it, the return is rejected. The client needs the Form 1095-A from the Health Insurance Marketplace to complete it.
- Ask every client about Marketplace coverage at intake, and collect every Form 1095-A.
- Do not use a Form 1095-A with the VOID box checked.
- If a 1095-A is wrong, the client can ask the Marketplace for a corrected one. For a change in circumstances that was never reported, the IRS explains how to work out the correct amounts.
6. A typo, or a form you left out
The IRS FAQ is plain about this: a wrong SSN, a misspelled name or an omitted form can be corrected and the return filed again electronically. This is why a last read of names, numbers and attached forms before you transmit pays for itself.
How long do you have?
- A rejected return is not a filed return. Do not tell a client "it was sent" until it is accepted.
- Rejected on or before the due date? Per Publication 1345, if it was submitted on or before the due date, it is treated as timely if you correct it and resubmit by the fifth calendar day after the due date.
- Cannot be fixed? File on paper by the later of the due date (including extensions) or 10 calendar days after the IRS notified you of the reject. Attach a copy of the rejection notice and an explanation of why you are filing after the due date.
- New signature? Corrected data can be retransmitted without new signatures if the change to the "amount you owe" stays within the tolerance in Publication 1345. A bigger change needs a new signed declaration (see Form 8879 for tax preparers).
- Timing: the Taxpayer Advocate Service says e-filers are usually told of a reject within about 24 hours. Transmit early, never on deadline day.
A routine that prevents most rejects
- At intake, collect the names and dates of birth exactly as on the Social Security cards, the SSN or ITIN of everyone on the return, last year's original AGI, any IP PIN, and every Form 1095-A. The document checklist for tax clients covers the full list. VYAX's Tax Organizer asks for the IP PIN of the taxpayer and spouse and about health coverage forms.
- Ask what changed: marriage, divorce, a name change, a new dependent, a move.
- Dependents: ask whether anyone else could claim them (for example, divorced parents).
- Before you transmit, re-read names and numbers against the documents and run your software's diagnostics.
- Transmit early, so a reject is a quick fix and not a missed deadline.
This article is general information, not tax or legal advice. Reject codes and procedures change by tax year, so confirm them against current IRS guidance and your software's reject text.